How picks are made and graded
Prop Desk Sports gives a verdict on each prop, then shows in public whether it was right. Here is exactly how.
1. The projection
For every player on tonight's slate the model projects minutes first, then production per minute, and combines them. It accounts for recent form, last season's role early in the year, teammates who are out, what tonight's opponent allows to guards, wings or bigs, pace, and for steals and blocks, tracking signals such as rim contests and live-ball turnovers.
The output is not just an average. It is a full range of outcomes, which gives the % chance of going over or under any line.
2. The edge
We take both sides of the line at each sportsbook, strip out the book's margin (the "vig") and average the result. That is the market's own % for the bet. Edge = our % minus the market's %, in percentage points, for the side we like.
Prices come only from major regulated sportsbooks: BetMGM, BetRivers, Caesars, DraftKings, FanDuel, Fanatics. Offshore books are excluded.
3. The Clean Edge rule
A pick becomes a Clean Edge, and goes on the public record, only if it passes all six checks:
- Steals or blocks only. Points, rebounds, assists and threes are still in private testing.
- Edge between 3 and 12 points: our % minus the sportsbooks' no-vig %. Bigger than 12 usually means the model missed news, so we pass.
- Positive expected value at the best available price.
- A real main line offered by at least 2 sportsbooks. No alternate lines.
- The player is not listed as questionable or day-to-day.
- A real reason behind it. No pick if the model has no standout factor, or leans only on deflections.
There is no nightly cap and no minimum. Some nights nothing passes.
4. Locking
- A pick is logged once, before its game starts, at the best price available at that moment. The time is saved with it.
- It is never re-priced, edited or deleted afterwards. Only the closing line and the result are added.
- Every pick is 1 unit, flat.
5. Grading
- Picks are graded the next morning from the final box score.
- Win pays at the locked odds; a loss costs 1 unit; a push returns the stake.
- If the player does not play, the pick is Void, the way sportsbooks treat it.
- We also record the closing line. A pick "beat the close" if the line moved our way, or the price on our side got at least 1 point of implied probability more expensive.
6. The numbers on the Results page
- Hit rate = wins ÷ (wins + losses). Break-even is the hit rate our posted prices needed.
- ROI = units won ÷ units staked on graded picks.
- Calibration groups picks by the % we gave our side and compares it with how often they won. For picks made before the site saved this number directly, it is rebuilt from the saved sportsbook lines and the edge recorded at lock time.
7. What is not here yet
Points, rebounds, assists and threes are tracked privately under the same six checks. A stat joins the Clean Edges and the public record only after it passes a live test: at least 14 game nights and 150 picks since Nov 2, a profit over that stretch, an average closing line that has not moved against us, and no single night making up more than half of the profit.
19+ only. Everything on this site is information, not betting advice. Past results do not guarantee future results.